Yaz88, I applaud you for being the problem-solver and the great equalizer. I too have been the problem-solver. You are right that there is an expectation for you to have it all figured out. But, my guess is at the end of the day you are too spent and just need the area of your life you desire most to work (POI) to indeed happen. And, consulting psychics over and over again just causes one to relive all the reasons why the relationship or lack of is not working.
In my case, I spent years in relationships waiting for the guy(s) to want to be in a committed relationship. With each relationship, I wised up to the point that one day something clicked in my brain and I no longer wanted to be with any of these clowns. It's humorous to me that today (15 years later) I see at least one of these guys from my past still trying to work towards commitment. All that has changed is that they are bald, fat, and trying to use the same old tricks with someone half their age.
It's only when you finally promise yourself that you won't take back someone who is flakey...and accept that you can't change someone who won't communicate (like you have).... that you really grow and attract the person you are meant to be with.