Author Topic: Can I Trust Multiple General Readings with the Same Predictions?  (Read 20738 times)

Offline KB

  • Newbie
  • *
  • Posts: 21
Re: Can I Trust Multiple General Readings with the Same Predictions?
« Reply #15 on: November 15, 2023, 05:08:38 AM »
Most readers will ask for specific questions or areas. I actually prefer general readings because I like to know what "spirit" wants me to know. I would usually ask for a general reading in the area of career and relationships and that I had a past relationship that ended in a confusing way that I might like to look back at. Thats it. Later i might offer more details but never upfront and I never specifically asked if my ex would return but I did ask if I might ever hear from her again or if we might salvage a friendship.


So many of them told me that someone from the past came back and interfered and she went back to him. That it was someone who had always been in the background. None of them knew that she had ended a 17 year relationship with a partner 6 months prior to meeting me and that they were still in contact as they shared a daughter - and I had even hung out with him a little. When they told me about an ex returning,  I was crushed and yet it made sooooo much sense. Yes, I know for a fact there was an ex "lingering" in the background - They also told me she suffered from mental health issues, impulsivity, that I had hit an "intimacy' threshold and he had panicked and run. The last month we were together I saw that too - panic attacks, she started hinting a little about having 2nd thoughts - but still insisted she valued me and loved me. Then we had one argument, and it was over. She refused to talk or mend it in any way, just said it was over. I was stunned. She admitted nothing about her ex to me but actually blamed me at first for not being present enough for her, the said she needed to be alone, maybe we could be friends...then she said she was uncomfortable pursuing a friendship with me...this was over the course of a couple of months of limited email contacted. When the psychics told me she had gone back to her ex, thats when it made sense that she had waffled said  maybe we could be friends then said no we could not....she was getting back with her ex and no doubt he was not going to accept her being friends with me nor did she want me to find out that was what she was doing - she had chased me, love bombed me, told me she valued and cherished me and I was the best relationship she had ever had and then left abruptly. I was blaming myself, could not eat, sleep for months. I had no familiarity with NPD and yet the psychics described her personality to a tee and the idealize, devalue and discard cycle  but most never using that label. Really they helped me incredibly to understand the real reasons for the break up and that it was not anything I had done. I got this same message from no tools psychics, tarot readers, etc. The redundancy was incredible - i was fascinated. They had to be picking up on something to all say the same thing, even at different sites.

BUT, the predictions of apologies and reconnections did not happen, and isn't it funny the CP psychics ALWAYS said, don't contact her, she will reach out to you. Why? To keep me waiting and hooked.  To be honest, the couple hundred readings I got became as much of a research project about the abilities of psychics (I am a science teacher) as it was me desperately wanting to understand our ending and if i would ever see her again . I have even considered writing a book about my experience of asking the same few questions of over a hundred psychics over the course of 2 years (yes I can get obsessed) .....if only she would come back and admit why she left, and I could then verify the readings. Unfortunately, we met online and have no mutual friends - so can't verify that way. But if she did get back with her ex and I could find out for sure, it would be the ultimate evidence that psychics can see things. The psychics also said she and he did not stay together, finding that out would also be amazing confirmation. But, she refuses to respond to my (very few) emails checking in with anything but a superficial hi I am doing great and hope you are too... and if I were to make contact with one of her friend to dig for a little info, it would just seem like i am a crazy stalker and I don't want that. Boy, would I like to find out what she had been up to the past two years....

Like I said, I got this information from different readers and from different sites (Keen, CP, Purple Garden and the College of Psychic studies) - it was uncanny. I have come to believe that psychics can pick up emotions and present and past, but forget predictions, particularly when it comes to another person's actions. I also believe the most popular readers are popular because they can tell coherent stories that appeal to people immensely - Dominique is a master at this, Mattie too - and Pilar. It's like you are reading a really good book you can't put down, so return to hear the next chapter (spending hundreds and thousands of dollars in the process). Some of the mid priced ones were much more real...telling me not to trust my ex. Even the high priced ones told me she had a lot of "work" to do, emotionally, but they indicted she was working and would return....I am finally 90% over the attachment and grief and would no longer welcome her with open arms, but I do still want to know what caused the abrupt ending and if the psychics were accurate.....

Offline Onyx

  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 103
Re: Can I Trust Multiple General Readings with the Same Predictions?
« Reply #16 on: November 15, 2023, 06:33:12 PM »
Most readers will ask for specific questions or areas. I actually prefer general readings because I like to know what "spirit" wants me to know. I would usually ask for a general reading in the area of career and relationships and that I had a past relationship that ended in a confusing way that I might like to look back at. Thats it. Later i might offer more details but never upfront and I never specifically asked if my ex would return but I did ask if I might ever hear from her again or if we might salvage a friendship.


So many of them told me that someone from the past came back and interfered and she went back to him. That it was someone who had always been in the background. None of them knew that she had ended a 17 year relationship with a partner 6 months prior to meeting me and that they were still in contact as they shared a daughter - and I had even hung out with him a little. When they told me about an ex returning,  I was crushed and yet it made sooooo much sense. Yes, I know for a fact there was an ex "lingering" in the background - They also told me she suffered from mental health issues, impulsivity, that I had hit an "intimacy' threshold and he had panicked and run. The last month we were together I saw that too - panic attacks, she started hinting a little about having 2nd thoughts - but still insisted she valued me and loved me. Then we had one argument, and it was over. She refused to talk or mend it in any way, just said it was over. I was stunned. She admitted nothing about her ex to me but actually blamed me at first for not being present enough for her, the said she needed to be alone, maybe we could be friends...then she said she was uncomfortable pursuing a friendship with me...this was over the course of a couple of months of limited email contacted. When the psychics told me she had gone back to her ex, thats when it made sense that she had waffled said  maybe we could be friends then said no we could not....she was getting back with her ex and no doubt he was not going to accept her being friends with me nor did she want me to find out that was what she was doing - she had chased me, love bombed me, told me she valued and cherished me and I was the best relationship she had ever had and then left abruptly. I was blaming myself, could not eat, sleep for months. I had no familiarity with NPD and yet the psychics described her personality to a tee and the idealize, devalue and discard cycle  but most never using that label. Really they helped me incredibly to understand the real reasons for the break up and that it was not anything I had done. I got this same message from no tools psychics, tarot readers, etc. The redundancy was incredible - i was fascinated. They had to be picking up on something to all say the same thing, even at different sites.

BUT, the predictions of apologies and reconnections did not happen, and isn't it funny the CP psychics ALWAYS said, don't contact her, she will reach out to you. Why? To keep me waiting and hooked.  To be honest, the couple hundred readings I got became as much of a research project about the abilities of psychics (I am a science teacher) as it was me desperately wanting to understand our ending and if i would ever see her again . I have even considered writing a book about my experience of asking the same few questions of over a hundred psychics over the course of 2 years (yes I can get obsessed) .....if only she would come back and admit why she left, and I could then verify the readings. Unfortunately, we met online and have no mutual friends - so can't verify that way. But if she did get back with her ex and I could find out for sure, it would be the ultimate evidence that psychics can see things. The psychics also said she and he did not stay together, finding that out would also be amazing confirmation. But, she refuses to respond to my (very few) emails checking in with anything but a superficial hi I am doing great and hope you are too... and if I were to make contact with one of her friend to dig for a little info, it would just seem like i am a crazy stalker and I don't want that. Boy, would I like to find out what she had been up to the past two years....

Like I said, I got this information from different readers and from different sites (Keen, CP, Purple Garden and the College of Psychic studies) - it was uncanny. I have come to believe that psychics can pick up emotions and present and past, but forget predictions, particularly when it comes to another person's actions. I also believe the most popular readers are popular because they can tell coherent stories that appeal to people immensely - Dominique is a master at this, Mattie too - and Pilar. It's like you are reading a really good book you can't put down, so return to hear the next chapter (spending hundreds and thousands of dollars in the process). Some of the mid priced ones were much more real...telling me not to trust my ex. Even the high priced ones told me she had a lot of "work" to do, emotionally, but they indicted she was working and would return....I am finally 90% over the attachment and grief and would no longer welcome her with open arms, but I do still want to know what caused the abrupt ending and if the psychics were accurate.....

Even if you find out she returned to an ex, it doesn't mean the psychic "saw" it. These readers are familiar with psychology and personality disorders. Narcissists and others like them follow certain behavior patterns.  So don't be so eager to think a psychic has a gift because they know psychology. Good luck!

Offline jackY

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 636
Re: Can I Trust Multiple General Readings with the Same Predictions?
« Reply #17 on: November 15, 2023, 11:37:12 PM »
Yes, and they have a 50/50 shot with a yes or no answer, right?


Most readers will ask for specific questions or areas. I actually prefer general readings because I like to know what "spirit" wants me to know. I would usually ask for a general reading in the area of career and relationships and that I had a past relationship that ended in a confusing way that I might like to look back at. Thats it. Later i might offer more details but never upfront and I never specifically asked if my ex would return but I did ask if I might ever hear from her again or if we might salvage a friendship.


So many of them told me that someone from the past came back and interfered and she went back to him. That it was someone who had always been in the background. None of them knew that she had ended a 17 year relationship with a partner 6 months prior to meeting me and that they were still in contact as they shared a daughter - and I had even hung out with him a little. When they told me about an ex returning,  I was crushed and yet it made sooooo much sense. Yes, I know for a fact there was an ex "lingering" in the background - They also told me she suffered from mental health issues, impulsivity, that I had hit an "intimacy' threshold and he had panicked and run. The last month we were together I saw that too - panic attacks, she started hinting a little about having 2nd thoughts - but still insisted she valued me and loved me. Then we had one argument, and it was over. She refused to talk or mend it in any way, just said it was over. I was stunned. She admitted nothing about her ex to me but actually blamed me at first for not being present enough for her, the said she needed to be alone, maybe we could be friends...then she said she was uncomfortable pursuing a friendship with me...this was over the course of a couple of months of limited email contacted. When the psychics told me she had gone back to her ex, thats when it made sense that she had waffled said  maybe we could be friends then said no we could not....she was getting back with her ex and no doubt he was not going to accept her being friends with me nor did she want me to find out that was what she was doing - she had chased me, love bombed me, told me she valued and cherished me and I was the best relationship she had ever had and then left abruptly. I was blaming myself, could not eat, sleep for months. I had no familiarity with NPD and yet the psychics described her personality to a tee and the idealize, devalue and discard cycle  but most never using that label. Really they helped me incredibly to understand the real reasons for the break up and that it was not anything I had done. I got this same message from no tools psychics, tarot readers, etc. The redundancy was incredible - i was fascinated. They had to be picking up on something to all say the same thing, even at different sites.

BUT, the predictions of apologies and reconnections did not happen, and isn't it funny the CP psychics ALWAYS said, don't contact her, she will reach out to you. Why? To keep me waiting and hooked.  To be honest, the couple hundred readings I got became as much of a research project about the abilities of psychics (I am a science teacher) as it was me desperately wanting to understand our ending and if i would ever see her again . I have even considered writing a book about my experience of asking the same few questions of over a hundred psychics over the course of 2 years (yes I can get obsessed) .....if only she would come back and admit why she left, and I could then verify the readings. Unfortunately, we met online and have no mutual friends - so can't verify that way. But if she did get back with her ex and I could find out for sure, it would be the ultimate evidence that psychics can see things. The psychics also said she and he did not stay together, finding that out would also be amazing confirmation. But, she refuses to respond to my (very few) emails checking in with anything but a superficial hi I am doing great and hope you are too... and if I were to make contact with one of her friend to dig for a little info, it would just seem like i am a crazy stalker and I don't want that. Boy, would I like to find out what she had been up to the past two years....

Like I said, I got this information from different readers and from different sites (Keen, CP, Purple Garden and the College of Psychic studies) - it was uncanny. I have come to believe that psychics can pick up emotions and present and past, but forget predictions, particularly when it comes to another person's actions. I also believe the most popular readers are popular because they can tell coherent stories that appeal to people immensely - Dominique is a master at this, Mattie too - and Pilar. It's like you are reading a really good book you can't put down, so return to hear the next chapter (spending hundreds and thousands of dollars in the process). Some of the mid priced ones were much more real...telling me not to trust my ex. Even the high priced ones told me she had a lot of "work" to do, emotionally, but they indicted she was working and would return....I am finally 90% over the attachment and grief and would no longer welcome her with open arms, but I do still want to know what caused the abrupt ending and if the psychics were accurate.....

Even if you find out she returned to an ex, it doesn't mean the psychic "saw" it. These readers are familiar with psychology and personality disorders. Narcissists and others like them follow certain behavior patterns.  So don't be so eager to think a psychic has a gift because they know psychology. Good luck!

Offline KB

  • Newbie
  • *
  • Posts: 21
Re: Can I Trust Multiple General Readings with the Same Predictions?
« Reply #18 on: November 16, 2023, 03:39:51 AM »
yeah I hear what you are saying - I guess the thing is, I never asked them if she had returned to an ex because it never dawned on me that she might have done that - completely off my radar.  And I never mentioned she had recent  ex that made that scenario highly plausible.... I never mentioned that the ex was always there, calling her, crying on her shoulder while we were dating, etc.

Still, these guys surely know about the likely scenarios. But, they could have said she found someone new.... they were specific that it was someone from the past that re-entered the picture....

Offline Cr1992

  • Newbie
  • *
  • Posts: 27
Re: Can I Trust Multiple General Readings with the Same Predictions?
« Reply #19 on: November 16, 2023, 05:28:06 PM »
@KB I try to stay away from anything that looks like a specific question unless the reader insists. I generally hang up if that's the case.

I literally go in asking for just a general reading on what's coming up for me over next few months. But still, who knows if they're just picking up on what's on my mind as the basis for those predictions. Time will tell, but not holding my breath lol.

I do think sometimes they read the present situation well and based on their personal perspective, make predictions on that current energy. So not always literally "seeing" things.

Offline thegreatestshow

  • Newbie
  • *
  • Posts: 14
Re: Can I Trust Multiple General Readings with the Same Predictions?
« Reply #20 on: November 22, 2023, 09:24:10 AM »
@thegreatestshow that's really interesting and I hope it ended up being positive for you that those predictions panned out?!

Aside from early on, I've only been asking for completely general readings. I ask, "What do you see for me over the next few months? What stands out to you?"

About 99% bring up an ex, among other things.... not just related to love, but in other areas of life, most of my readings have been eerily similar. Too soon to know if that will mean anything though.

Ah.. the one with the ex fling returning, i was told to ignore and not entertain but i refused to and i got hurt badly hahaha but yes things otherwise have been better!

I see. I do notice that most (inethical) readers bait with exes returning.. but like you said, too soon to know, good luck with the readings!

Offline Signs123

  • Newbie
  • *
  • Posts: 18
Re: Can I Trust Multiple General Readings with the Same Predictions?
« Reply #21 on: November 15, 2025, 07:48:32 PM »
Hi everyone!

I've had SEVERAL general readings over the last couple months with very reputable readers, including Yona Farrell (storefront), Mattie (CP), Uli (CP), Effie (CP), Jeremiah (CP), Bridgette (PS), Chip (CP), Asia (CP), Tajah (CP), Angelica (PS), Rika (CP), Nina (CP), Pilar (CP), etc.

Without me sharing any of my own thoughts and being fairly silent throughout each general reading, these readers all made roughly the exact same predictions for me with similar timeframes---including a prediction that a specific ex would be in contact in the November/December timeframe. Again, I did not ask about this, each reader just picked it up on their own along with the other things they predicted.

By contrast, a couple of less known/less reputable readers (3-4) gave almost exactly the same general reading as the numerous reputable readers; HOWEVER, they did not seem to pick up on the ex at all, so I would then ask directly about what they saw. In these instances, they would then say "no," they did not see him getting in touch. The readers who predicted no contact were just random readers, no reputation really. Just gave them a try.

My questions for you all:


1) Has anyone received the same prediction across numerous general readings (with no leading information provided) and it DIDN'T come true?

2) If a prediction is made during a general reading without any leading information from me, how likely is it to be true?

3) If the same prediction is made across a majority of general readings with highly reputable readers, how likely is it to be true?

4) Could all these highly similar general readings simply just be a reflection of my thoughts/energy/hopes/wishes/dreams/fears? Or is that less likely to be the case since the prediction has been consistent across the majority of general readings with both reputable and unknown readers?   

5) Do general readings tend to be more accurate than specific question readings?

Any insights/knowledge/guidance anyone can share as to the above questions would be greatly appreciated. Also happy to answer any questions in return!

Did anything come to pass since this?

Offline Miss Philosopher

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 434
Re: Can I Trust Multiple General Readings with the Same Predictions?
« Reply #22 on: November 15, 2025, 09:12:51 PM »
Hi everyone!

I've had SEVERAL general readings over the last couple months with very reputable readers, including Yona Farrell (storefront), Mattie (CP), Uli (CP), Effie (CP), Jeremiah (CP), Bridgette (PS), Chip (CP), Asia (CP), Tajah (CP), Angelica (PS), Rika (CP), Nina (CP), Pilar (CP), etc.

Without me sharing any of my own thoughts and being fairly silent throughout each general reading, these readers all made roughly the exact same predictions for me with similar timeframes---including a prediction that a specific ex would be in contact in the November/December timeframe. Again, I did not ask about this, each reader just picked it up on their own along with the other things they predicted.

By contrast, a couple of less known/less reputable readers (3-4) gave almost exactly the same general reading as the numerous reputable readers; HOWEVER, they did not seem to pick up on the ex at all, so I would then ask directly about what they saw. In these instances, they would then say "no," they did not see him getting in touch. The readers who predicted no contact were just random readers, no reputation really. Just gave them a try.

My questions for you all:


1) Has anyone received the same prediction across numerous general readings (with no leading information provided) and it DIDN'T come true?

2) If a prediction is made during a general reading without any leading information from me, how likely is it to be true?

3) If the same prediction is made across a majority of general readings with highly reputable readers, how likely is it to be true?

4) Could all these highly similar general readings simply just be a reflection of my thoughts/energy/hopes/wishes/dreams/fears? Or is that less likely to be the case since the prediction has been consistent across the majority of general readings with both reputable and unknown readers?   

5) Do general readings tend to be more accurate than specific question readings?

Any insights/knowledge/guidance anyone can share as to the above questions would be greatly appreciated. Also happy to answer any questions in return!

1. I've only received general readings from three readers ever. Kisha (retired) and her general readings were ALWAYS right. Yona (only read with her once in 2020 and it was a general read and all of it unfolded over about a 3 year period). Sincerity and her generals are still pending as I just recently got them. I will say that Sincerity's current general readings match Kisha's previous general readings so I'm confident in those coming to pass at some point. As a side note, the majority of the readers you listed are from CP. I can't say that CP readers are "reputable" due to the fact that CP does not allow negative reviews to be posted. Therefore, you will always only see positive reviews. Additionally,  in the distant past, like 15 years ago distant, I tried soooooooooo many CP readers and they were ALL WRONG. Uli, Aliza, Venus, and on and on and on. But those weren't general readings back then but still. I don't think CP has good psychics at all.

2. It's hard to predict a likelihood of anything being "true" because we live in a big soup bowl full of potentials and possibilities. I will say this much. When you get readings with soooooo many different psychics within a short span of time (months), it can make the accuracy of any one reading not so great and just a copy of the previous because everything and everyone is an energy. Each interaction you have with someone is allowing their energy into your energy. Get where I'm going with this? 

3. Just because multiple readers say the same thing doesn't make it more or less likely to be "true". Back when I was reading in 2010, I swear I must have called at least 100 or more different psychics off of CP and Keen and pretty much all of them gave me the same "outcome" other than two. Kisha and Nicole4sees. And guess what? Those two were the only two that ended up being right. :/ It's a huge reason I stopped getting readings with multiple readers. I recommend only reading with one or two, MAYBE three readers who have proven to be consistently accurate with their predictions with a 90% accuracy rate or more. But that's just my own standard. Anything less than 90% to me is just good guesses.

4. Yes it is possible that they could just be reading your own wants/needs/fears. That's why it's so important to thoroughly vet a psychic. For me, a psychic must be a no tools reader that is at the very least a clairvoyant. I don't really like mediums much because they're really only good for communicating with the other side which isn't what I'm interested in. So they MUST be clairvoyant. They can have additional abilities like empath, clairsentient, clairaudient, remote viewing etc. added on but their main gift must be clairvoyance. That said, only choose one or two and stick with those.

5. I think general readings absolutely do tend to be much more accurate than specific questions. That's been my experience anyway. You did mention that many of them talked about your ex reaching out in November/December. Please keep in mind that some of these psychics will also base there readings and predictions on astrological influences such as.......Mercury retrograde which those energies have been present all of November and will continue throughout December. As we all know, mercury retrograde is an energy that is known as a time when people from the past resurface out of nowhere because that's the energy of Mercury retrograde. All about the past.

 

anything