Author Topic: Cookie from Keen - Feeling defeated  (Read 2259 times)

Offline Sparkle002

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1553
  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: Cookie from Keen - Feeling defeated
« Reply #30 on: October 06, 2018, 01:22:20 PM »
Well that doesn't make any sense. If they aren't on Keen or on a platform, there is no incentive to keep callers on the phone, like some are describing.
Keen makes their money by keeping callers on the phone as all platforms do.

This cookie has her own site: http://psychicreadingsbycookie.com, but I'm not sure if some have read with her.
Kasamba has a Cookie: https://www.californiapsychics.com/psychics/cookie-6648

There is a Cookie in Melburne and a free Cookie here: http://www.anybodythere.net/psychic-readings-cookie.php

The Cookie on Keen is called "Spiritualist Reader"
https://www.keen.com/psychic-readings/otherworld-connections/spiritualist-reader/1180159?category=0&gid=0&pmode=0&flmode=call&pageid=26

I hope no one has confused the Cookie on Keen with those above!! That would suck lol :o

Yes, I am talking about Spiritualist Reader on Keen aka Cookie. She was my go-to years ago and I called her a lot more than I want to admit. I am giving an honest review of my experience here because she did lead me on.

My experience with readers has taught me not to defend or make excuses for psychics. Back in the day, I would be the first to defend Cookie because I loved her future outlook with my then POI. Years later when nothing happened, I realized she just wasn't worth my time or money. If she works for others, that's excellent but I stay as far as I can from her now.

Thanks so much for your honest review. I agree it is true everyone connects with readers differently.
Cookie has picked up things for me - but is definitely not my go-to lol
Its interesting how differently readers connect!

Offline Kate

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 562
  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: Cookie from Keen - Feeling defeated
« Reply #31 on: October 06, 2018, 05:12:55 PM »
Well that doesn't make any sense. If they aren't on Keen or on a platform, there is no incentive to keep callers on the phone, like some are describing.
Keen makes their money by keeping callers on the phone as all platforms do.

This cookie has her own site: http://psychicreadingsbycookie.com, but I'm not sure if some have read with her.
Kasamba has a Cookie: https://www.californiapsychics.com/psychics/cookie-6648

There is a Cookie in Melburne and a free Cookie here: http://www.anybodythere.net/psychic-readings-cookie.php

The Cookie on Keen is called "Spiritualist Reader"
https://www.keen.com/psychic-readings/otherworld-connections/spiritualist-reader/1180159?category=0&gid=0&pmode=0&flmode=call&pageid=26

I hope no one has confused the Cookie on Keen with those above!! That would suck lol :o

Yes, I am talking about Spiritualist Reader on Keen aka Cookie. She was my go-to years ago and I called her a lot more than I want to admit. I am giving an honest review of my experience here because she did lead me on.

My experience with readers has taught me not to defend or make excuses for psychics. Back in the day, I would be the first to defend Cookie because I loved her future outlook with my then POI. Years later when nothing happened, I realized she just wasn't worth my time or money. If she works for others, that's excellent but I stay as far as I can from her now.

Thanks so much for your honest review. I agree it is true everyone connects with readers differently.
Cookie has picked up things for me - but is definitely not my go-to lol
Its interesting how differently readers connect!

Yeah it is - she has never been inaccurate with me.. in fact, she has changed the whole way I look upon the world as her ability to see my future has been so so accurate - and many times I didn't believe what she said would happen.. sometimes I hoped it wouldn't.. anyway. Ultimately, I think it's best not to call, accurate or not.. just best to live life, rather than live in fear or anticipation of a prediction..

Offline Alwayzunique

  • Regular Members
  • *
  • Posts: 15
  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: Cookie from Keen - Feeling defeated
« Reply #32 on: October 07, 2018, 02:19:30 AM »
I really wish everyone who thinks Cookie is slow and unethical would get out of her que so that I can read with her sooner. lol

I've read with her a long time and she has been great for me. She has been accurate and has helped me foresee things in many instances.
No worries because I won’t be calling her back so now there will be 99 in queue instead of 100.

Offline Alwayzunique

  • Regular Members
  • *
  • Posts: 15
  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: Cookie from Keen - Feeling defeated
« Reply #33 on: October 07, 2018, 02:34:00 AM »


Cookie has no need to keep anyone on the phone longer - she has a list of over 100 clients at any one time for crying out loud, and it's not her main family income.

That's not a lot. It takes her at least a month to go through 100 calls. There's readers that go through 30 -40 a day on keen.
I don’t think she gets to all the people in her queue. I think a lot of them fall off after time. Keen will only allow you to hold your spot for up to 1 month. (that’s how it is on the web I don’t know if they can extend longer if you call customer service). Anyway....when I 1st jumped in her queue I was 100something. Not knowing how long it would take I checked multiple times a day to see when she was on and she was almost never there. Every couple days I would go back to the schedule and extend it again to 30 days so I wouldn’t fall off. By the time I got down to like 15. I started keeping the phone with me at night because that’s the only time I saw her on. After that I started noticing she was only taking like 2 or 3 calls any night she was on because my position in her queue was only decreasing in 2’s. The night I finally got her.....I was #3 when she logged on.

BTW....I am talking about Cookie from Keen/Spiritual Reader.

Offline Alwayzunique

  • Regular Members
  • *
  • Posts: 15
  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: Cookie from Keen - Feeling defeated
« Reply #34 on: October 07, 2018, 02:43:49 AM »
are you sure that's  the cookie we are talking about?

Not here to point fingers but calling a spade a spade. Cookie has kept me on the phone longer than need be and used to email me back in the day saying she has "messages" for me to tempt me to make an appointment with her. When I would call her to get the "message", it would be nothing remarkable, just my previous reading re-hashed.

She has been a 100% wrong for me, be it relationship or career related.

Wow! So weird she didnt come off as that type to do that wow
Everyone's experience with her is definitely interesting to say the least

Yea I don’t believe that. There’s another reader that calls herself Cookie that’s not from Keen so maybe she’s being mixed up here.

I can’t speak for others but I know I am talking about the same Cookie. On Keen she is listed as Spiritual Reader. Each time I attempted to end the call she would either bring up something I didn’t ask about or reiterate what she had already said.

Offline Alwayzunique

  • Regular Members
  • *
  • Posts: 15
  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: Cookie from Keen - Feeling defeated
« Reply #35 on: October 07, 2018, 03:07:20 AM »
She was definitely trying to keep me on the phone longer which is unethical. Everytime I said "thank you for your time" she would either bring up something I didn't ask about or repeat the same thing she said earlier and I continued to stay because I truly believed based on how highly you all talk about her that she was gonna give me answers but she didn't. All she said was this could happen or this might happen nothing was concrete. I waited 2 months to talk to her and I still have no answers. I spent a ridiculous amount of money talking to her yesterday cuz I wanted to believe she would give me something that she didn't.
“Not unethical” wouldn’t it be more ethical if she would just say she doesn’t know instead of eating up your time with the “maybes” in which she’s not really seeing. The “maybes” which are different scenarios that could happen which is the reason why we go to these psychics to begin with because we know it has to go one way or another.

Cookie has no need to keep anyone on the phone longer - she has a list of over 100 clients at any one time for crying out loud, and it's not her main family income.

Sometimes she has fallen silent with me, and when I haven't gone, asked "did you have another question?" she's not a reader that strings things out if she can't see something for the sake of it.

I understand the pain of a bad reading - I've had vague readings in my time with Cookie where I wished I had not called, but then, that's the same with any reader! 

She is not unethical. I've had her tell me, she doesn't care if I never call again, she is going to tell me the truth regardless..etc I've even had her tell me not to call because it's a bad decision financially. This doesn't speak of a reader desperate to keep people on the phone. The evidence is not there to back you up.

Try for a refund via Keen - good luck on that, they are very strict with their refunds at the moment - I hope you get it, simply because I loathe Keen. But don't label readers as unethical just because you didn't get an answer you wanted, or it cost, or they were slow talkers... The ones who are unethical in my opinion, are those that tell you only good news to keep you calling (despite seeing the opposite), charge over $30 a min, change for spells, or know that they are frauds with zero talent .. Cookie none of the above

In regard to Cookie's advice to reach out - she is one of the only readers that will tell you not to wait.  Good on her for that. 

She called me once and instructed me to reach out, send a text there and then telling my POI where I was - told me that if I did, it would advance things forward dramatically.

I pushed against it - I was scared, said there was no point because the person I was reaching out to was not in town. I'd had read with Advisor Neal who told me to only reach out when he reached out - so I was stubborn and reluctant.  Anyway - she stuck to it, and eventually - while she was on the phone with me still - I sent him a text message.  What happened?  Turned out he was in the same town as me, he invited me out, and we reconnected, and it was wonderful.

You can bash her all you like - I agree that not all readings with Cookie are great - some seem like a waste of time. But whatever you say, I and many others have evidence of this lady's talent - and accept the high price of a call (and some bad calls) to glean information from her.

IN regard to her advice re the LoA.  Cookie is also one of the only readers that will encourage you to work on changing a bad reading - if she sees that you want something, but cannot see it happening, she will tell you how to change it.  I've worked on this with her, and had dramatic changes.. it's worth the effort.

I know I come across as Cookie's no1 fan.  I am biased because my experiences with her have generally been So very positive.  BUT - as I said above, I have had bad readings also - after my first reading with her, I almost didn't return.  I only did, because one minor prediction came true..and in desperate of reading with many bad people, I decided to give her another shot. SO SO thankful I did. 

I don't like any readers that charge over $5 a min.  It would be better if Cookie had her own site, and was able to cut the cost down without paying half the fee to the platform. But, without that option, I am willing to accept and pay the cost for 99% accurate info and no BS.

Sorry all - just realised I'm mixing some replies re Cookie on this thread (her being unethical and talking about the LoA), and comments about her on her main thread (re reaching out to your POI).

I want to just say again, that I am sorry you had a bad reading, I'm not having a go at you, I recognise that we're all in the same boat here - doing our best to navigate intense emotional connections that test us to the core, and trying in the process to survive without spending a fortune on psychics.

It's just I know Cookie very well, and I know she is not unethical in nature, or practice. Some reads with her are amazing, others are vague.. if she can't see a clear defined answer, she will give you a "it might happen" and then it is up to you...She is a better short term event reader, than long term. But her reads with me long term have also been spot on.. I guess I have a very good connection with her as a reader - and not so much with others on the thread that have amazing reputations (like Keisha who recently told me she cannot connect to me).

Apologies again for answering on one thread, comments related to her other thread! :) Hopefully they are all useful comments.

Offline Alwayzunique

  • Regular Members
  • *
  • Posts: 15
  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: Cookie from Keen - Feeling defeated
« Reply #36 on: October 07, 2018, 03:20:33 AM »
She was definitely trying to keep me on the phone longer which is unethical. Everytime I said "thank you for your time" she would either bring up something I didn't ask about or repeat the same thing she said earlier and I continued to stay because I truly believed based on how highly you all talk about her that she was gonna give me answers but she didn't. All she said was this could happen or this might happen nothing was concrete. I waited 2 months to talk to her and I still have no answers. I spent a ridiculous amount of money talking to her yesterday cuz I wanted to believe she would give me something that she didn't.

Cookie has no need to keep anyone on the phone longer - she has a list of over 100 clients at any one time for crying out loud, and it's not her main family income.

Sometimes she has fallen silent with me, and when I haven't gone, asked "did you have another question?" she's not a reader that strings things out if she can't see something for the sake of it.

I understand the pain of a bad reading - I've had vague readings in my time with Cookie where I wished I had not called, but then, that's the same with any reader! 

She is not unethical. I've had her tell me, she doesn't care if I never call again, she is going to tell me the truth regardless..etc I've even had her tell me not to call because it's a bad decision financially. This doesn't speak of a reader desperate to keep people on the phone. The evidence is not there to back you up.

Try for a refund via Keen - good luck on that, they are very strict with their refunds at the moment - I hope you get it, simply because I loathe Keen. But don't label readers as unethical just because you didn't get an answer you wanted, or it cost, or they were slow talkers... The ones who are unethical in my opinion, are those that tell you only good news to keep you calling (despite seeing the opposite), charge over $30 a min, change for spells, or know that they are frauds with zero talent .. Cookie none of the above

In regard to Cookie's advice to reach out - she is one of the only readers that will tell you not to wait.  Good on her for that. 

She called me once and instructed me to reach out, send a text there and then telling my POI where I was - told me that if I did, it would advance things forward dramatically.

I pushed against it - I was scared, said there was no point because the person I was reaching out to was not in town. I'd had read with Advisor Neal who told me to only reach out when he reached out - so I was stubborn and reluctant.  Anyway - she stuck to it, and eventually - while she was on the phone with me still - I sent him a text message.  What happened?  Turned out he was in the same town as me, he invited me out, and we reconnected, and it was wonderful.

You can bash her all you like - I agree that not all readings with Cookie are great - some seem like a waste of time. But whatever you say, I and many others have evidence of this lady's talent - and accept the high price of a call (and some bad calls) to glean information from her.

IN regard to her advice re the LoA.  Cookie is also one of the only readers that will encourage you to work on changing a bad reading - if she sees that you want something, but cannot see it happening, she will tell you how to change it.  I've worked on this with her, and had dramatic changes.. it's worth the effort.

I know I come across as Cookie's no1 fan.  I am biased because my experiences with her have generally been So very positive.  BUT - as I said above, I have had bad readings also - after my first reading with her, I almost didn't return.  I only did, because one minor prediction came true..and in desperate of reading with many bad people, I decided to give her another shot. SO SO thankful I did. 

I don't like any readers that charge over $5 a min.  It would be better if Cookie had her own site, and was able to cut the cost down without paying half the fee to the platform. But, without that option, I am willing to accept and pay the cost for 99% accurate info and no BS.

Sorry all - just realised I'm mixing some replies re Cookie on this thread (her being unethical and talking about the LoA), and comments about her on her main thread (re reaching out to your POI).

I want to just say again, that I am sorry you had a bad reading, I'm not having a go at you, I recognise that we're all in the same boat here - doing our best to navigate intense emotional connections that test us to the core, and trying in the process to survive without spending a fortune on psychics.

It's just I know Cookie very well, and I know she is not unethical in nature, or practice. Some reads with her are amazing, others are vague.. if she can't see a clear defined answer, she will give you a "it might happen" and then it is up to you...She is a better short term event reader, than long term. But her reads with me long term have also been spot on.. I guess I have a very good connection with her as a reader - and not so much with others on the thread that have amazing reputations (like Keisha who recently told me she cannot connect to me).

Apologies again for answering on one thread, comments related to her other thread! :) Hopefully they are all useful comments.

“Not unethical” wouldn’t it be more ethical for her to just say she doesn’t know instead of eating up your time with the “maybes” that she’s not really seeing anyway? The “maybes” that are causing us to call her in the 1st place. We already know the multitude of ways an issue can play out none of us are calling for maybes. Sounds like Keisha maybe more ethical in this case because at least she is straight up in telling you she’s unable to read you.

Offline Kate

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 562
  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: Cookie from Keen - Feeling defeated
« Reply #37 on: October 07, 2018, 04:56:25 AM »
She was definitely trying to keep me on the phone longer which is unethical. Everytime I said "thank you for your time" she would either bring up something I didn't ask about or repeat the same thing she said earlier and I continued to stay because I truly believed based on how highly you all talk about her that she was gonna give me answers but she didn't. All she said was this could happen or this might happen nothing was concrete. I waited 2 months to talk to her and I still have no answers. I spent a ridiculous amount of money talking to her yesterday cuz I wanted to believe she would give me something that she didn't.

Cookie has no need to keep anyone on the phone longer - she has a list of over 100 clients at any one time for crying out loud, and it's not her main family income.

Sometimes she has fallen silent with me, and when I haven't gone, asked "did you have another question?" she's not a reader that strings things out if she can't see something for the sake of it.

I understand the pain of a bad reading - I've had vague readings in my time with Cookie where I wished I had not called, but then, that's the same with any reader! 

She is not unethical. I've had her tell me, she doesn't care if I never call again, she is going to tell me the truth regardless..etc I've even had her tell me not to call because it's a bad decision financially. This doesn't speak of a reader desperate to keep people on the phone. The evidence is not there to back you up.

Try for a refund via Keen - good luck on that, they are very strict with their refunds at the moment - I hope you get it, simply because I loathe Keen. But don't label readers as unethical just because you didn't get an answer you wanted, or it cost, or they were slow talkers... The ones who are unethical in my opinion, are those that tell you only good news to keep you calling (despite seeing the opposite), charge over $30 a min, change for spells, or know that they are frauds with zero talent .. Cookie none of the above

In regard to Cookie's advice to reach out - she is one of the only readers that will tell you not to wait.  Good on her for that. 

She called me once and instructed me to reach out, send a text there and then telling my POI where I was - told me that if I did, it would advance things forward dramatically.

I pushed against it - I was scared, said there was no point because the person I was reaching out to was not in town. I'd had read with Advisor Neal who told me to only reach out when he reached out - so I was stubborn and reluctant.  Anyway - she stuck to it, and eventually - while she was on the phone with me still - I sent him a text message.  What happened?  Turned out he was in the same town as me, he invited me out, and we reconnected, and it was wonderful.

You can bash her all you like - I agree that not all readings with Cookie are great - some seem like a waste of time. But whatever you say, I and many others have evidence of this lady's talent - and accept the high price of a call (and some bad calls) to glean information from her.

IN regard to her advice re the LoA.  Cookie is also one of the only readers that will encourage you to work on changing a bad reading - if she sees that you want something, but cannot see it happening, she will tell you how to change it.  I've worked on this with her, and had dramatic changes.. it's worth the effort.

I know I come across as Cookie's no1 fan.  I am biased because my experiences with her have generally been So very positive.  BUT - as I said above, I have had bad readings also - after my first reading with her, I almost didn't return.  I only did, because one minor prediction came true..and in desperate of reading with many bad people, I decided to give her another shot. SO SO thankful I did. 

I don't like any readers that charge over $5 a min.  It would be better if Cookie had her own site, and was able to cut the cost down without paying half the fee to the platform. But, without that option, I am willing to accept and pay the cost for 99% accurate info and no BS.

Sorry all - just realised I'm mixing some replies re Cookie on this thread (her being unethical and talking about the LoA), and comments about her on her main thread (re reaching out to your POI).

I want to just say again, that I am sorry you had a bad reading, I'm not having a go at you, I recognise that we're all in the same boat here - doing our best to navigate intense emotional connections that test us to the core, and trying in the process to survive without spending a fortune on psychics.

It's just I know Cookie very well, and I know she is not unethical in nature, or practice. Some reads with her are amazing, others are vague.. if she can't see a clear defined answer, she will give you a "it might happen" and then it is up to you...She is a better short term event reader, than long term. But her reads with me long term have also been spot on.. I guess I have a very good connection with her as a reader - and not so much with others on the thread that have amazing reputations (like Keisha who recently told me she cannot connect to me).

Apologies again for answering on one thread, comments related to her other thread! :) Hopefully they are all useful comments.

“Not unethical” wouldn’t it be more ethical for her to just say she doesn’t know instead of eating up your time with the “maybes” that she’s not really seeing anyway? The “maybes” that are causing us to call her in the 1st place. We already know the multitude of ways an issue can play out none of us are calling for maybes. Sounds like Keisha maybe more ethical in this case because at least she is straight up in telling you she’s unable to read you.

Well if you ask her a question, she is going to try and answer it.  Every reader I have ever spoken to on an instant call will do that ..

I've had quite long conversations with Cookie about this.  She has consistently told me - whenever I question a not clear answer - that she can only tell me what she sees.  And, from what I know, if she sees a unclear answer, you CAN change it.. it's not set in stone..

However, sometimes I ponder that some answers are not supposed to be open to us.

I had one situation very early this year, that if she had seen it, I would never have let it happen - what she did see was a change in energy between me and my POI - what caused it was an event that she did not see.. a very very significant event.  I believe somethings are not meant to be seen clearly. 

The costs of Cookie are high - especially for those of us that are not in the US and have to deal with the conversion rates on the dollar also. But because most of the things she has seen for me have come to pass.. especially those things she has seen without me prompting.. I have put up with other stuff that may not be clear.

She is miles away from other readers who will string you along with answers that are just BS.. at least she won't lie to you.  That's why I call - I want the truth.. and I want to be able to change it if I don't like it.

Anyway - I guess you won't be calling her again, so..