GreenGrl,
I would try Seha, Ricky, or Ellen Hartwell. I also feel as though Tatiana was very honest with me.
I tend to just provide my ex's name and say "Can you tell me anything about my relationship with ______?" and then let them go. I don't like leading questions, I don't like when they ask me questions. I like to answer "yes" or "no" and let them read from there. I have worked with psychics for years to help with guidance and where I should be focusing my energy. Things change. We have paths our lives can take. Maybe the path a reader is seeing is one way things can go, but there may be another you might not ever know exists because you are focused on one particular situation. In my experience, when a reader is looking at someone's energy and your path in relation to them and your relationship - you can also have them look at the path and energy of your life without this person.
It is very easy for timelines to be wrong or off. Time is much more fluid than linear. That is one of the best things the spiritual advisors I have worked with outside PS and CP are honest about. Some psychics can only see a few weeks in advance clearly, then they can see energy into upcoming months and the next year, and sometimes things get too blurry after that. I am not advising you should spend more money to keep getting different answers, but I do believe there are readers (especially on the sites that charge upwards of 10 dollars a minute) who will sugarcoat or not dive deep enough into your and the other individuals energy. Also, I do believe it's difficult for psychics to spend 5 or 6 hours reading people. I know energy and vibration have a huge part in being an intuitive - and every person I know who is psychic spends time between readings "cleansing". (Sidenote, for my friends who are psychic, it is almost impossible for them to read my own situation, as they have their own personal bias and know me too well to give readings without being somewhat judgey - either positive or negative. This is part of the reason I turned to the sites to begin with).
I can tell you that there are readers who are legitimate, there are readers who don't really try that hard and are burnt out, but there is also freewill. Something, which may be communicated many times by various readers to you - can change if your course changes. Additionally, I know the intuitive people I know can read the energy of my ex better when I have seen him (maybe this isn't all of them, but it's definitely true for some).
Hopefully some of this is helpful in how you approach readings going forward. I 100% believe in psychics. My friend Drew who is psychic and uses playing cards to access the Akashic records and his guides will admittedly say psychics are usually a lot closer to 85% correct if they are truly psychic.
In my experience in calling the readers on the sites the last couple weeks, and in reading all of your experiences - I do believe there are some straight crooks out there who will get you on the phone and just read into everything you're saying and just make stuff up. We are all intuitive and psychic. When push comes to shove, listen to your guts.
Liz