There are hundreds of readers that can make you feel good in the moment because they have a soothing tone or know what to say to placate or postpone harsher realities. I think QoC is one who refuses to do that and I personally consider that to be a more ethical approach. I get that it's not pleasant to hear an annoyed tone in a reader's voice, but I'd prefer to pay for that (if it's real) than to pay someone ultra sweet who is jus stringing me along...
I think a good reader is someone who can determine which is the best approach for the caller in the moment. Some people need compassion and gentleness. I don't think that's "stringing" anyone along.
With Anne, based on my experience, she wasn't giving tough love. Her vibe was more, "Why are you wasting my time, you f-cking idiot?" When you're already anxious about the POI you're calling about, having intensity blasted at you isn't always the best thing.
Sure, if you have an established connection with Anne, and you've asked the same question a bunch of times, then her being direct would be beneficial.
I just remember, back when I was calling Keen a lot, calling Anne was a low point. I was feeling so vulnerable and out of my mind at that time. After she spoke to me as harshly as she did, I hung up feeling really unsettled for a couple of hours afterward. Then the shame set in. Who in their right mind pays to talk to someone on Keen only to be left feeling bad for calling in the first place?
She's awful.
That's certainly fair and just to clarify -- anne has never yelled at me or been overly harsh. She's been irritable and annoyed -- mildly -- on a couple of occasions. Cookie has also lost patience with me a couple of times when I wasn't really listening to her advice.
If a reader was in any way abusive or mean to me, I would absolutely not call them again. I'm sorry that happened to you (or anyone) with Anne and if it does to me in the future it'll be my last call to her. I have had experiences like that, where the reader may have been right but they were so harsh that I will never call again. It's just not worth it... So I suppose I modify my earlier response to say that no reader -- no matter how talented -- should be able to yell or abuse a client. I can handle an annoyed tone -- not abuse.
I do think some of the readers who are overly sweet CAn be quite dangerous in a different way. If their main objective is to make you feel all warm and fuzzy and that means not telling the truth, possibly for years, that's a more passive type of abuse IMO. But I suppose that's also a different issue.
** Sorry, I posted too soon. Just editing this to add that:
- Just wanted to clarify that I wasn't suggesting that all readers whose vibe is compassion and kindness are "stringing you along", I meant when they really are stringing you along...
- My favourite type of reader is able to do both - be honest and share even the harder to hear truths AND deliver with kindness and compassion. This is ideal. It's just so hard to find the ones that have a real talent that I am willing to put up with some less than ideal delivery (Not abuse) at times