Metaphysical, Spiritual and Psychic Discussions > Samadi

Has anyone tried her

<< < (5/6) > >>

elcaliente:
I understand, but given that timing is particularly difficult for any psychic to get exact, in my mind the real "prediction" is the favourable "outcome".  Now if it just happens that a time for an event, such as contact, does occur within a timeframe given, then I can see how members could report that a prediction has come to pass, but if that contact did not occur within a timeframe give, do you also believe it is accurate to report that a "prediction" did not come to pass?  After all, many psychics can't give exact times for events, and expecially when so many things can impact timing of events.

Let me put it this way, for me, the outcome of a particular situation is what I focus on. The psychic reports that "someone will be back in my life" .  To know if there might be times of contact between now and then is helpful to me, but the end result is what I am concerned with.  If I have been given a favourable report for outcome, and certain contact dates that were given have passed with no result, should I be considering that the psychic's prediction of a favourable outcome is then not accurate or flawed?

sunandmoon:
This brings us back to: when do you just say it hasn't happened. If a psychic says a person will be back in your life by October 2012, at what point do you say ok they were wrong? November 2012? October 2013? Beyond?

If a psychic is NOT good with timing then they shouldn't be giving dates, just outcomes. Dave on CP rarely will give timing as he doesn't believe in it - to me that's being honest.

SomethingBetter:
When people say here, "prediction didn't happen." more often than not its the outcome. Read back to the beginning of the board. Almost none of those people post anymore. They were all told someone would come back and that someone didn't. Some gave up on having their ex back, some found new relationships and some even found out their exes got married. So it's two fold, the "lesser" predictions of contact usually never happened and the "major" prediction of reconciliation almost certainly didn't.

I will say a lot of people it seems in the inception of this board were hardcore CP fans. I mean no disrespect when I say this so I hope no one takes offense, but anyone reading with CP, unless someone has accurately predicted future events for you...don't read there. They are just a bunch of fakes and possibly empaths. Yes people want to know how someone feels, but a good clairvoyant can tell you that AND future predictions. It breaks my heart to see how much that site has cause pain to people here. I mean that is their business model, to spit out the same excuses sunandmoon talked about and feed people false hope, making them wait, while the other person moves on. I know it's an oxymoron of sorts to speak of a "real" psychic, but at least on keen there are a few.

It's hard. Reading with psychics can't be taken from a quantitative approach. Of course everyone will tell you so and so is coming back. And it's usually the two or 3 that tell someone the opposite who is right. But we discount them and conveniently forget them. You really have to take it from a qualitative standpoint. Did you have to give info/could you ask a test question that they got correctly/could they give an accurate short term prediction, etc.

Sorry, got on a tangent, but overall...about 95% here did not have a final outcome happen as they were told. Usually the opposite. That isn't a timing issue, that is being flat out wrong. To me, outcome is more important that smaller contact predictions. BUT if there is no contact or anything, it's hard to swallow that this person will magically swoop back in.

It's pretty much a crapshoot. Just find one or two honest readers, try them for a bit, see if they have short term stuff that pans out and stick to them.

elcaliente:
Well that's exactly what I am getting at.  If a pyshich sees that the outcome will be a positive one, and gives a fair estimate on when that might or might not occur, but also estimates that there could be contact initiated at some point along the way.  If that contact does not occur, yet the outcome is still some way off, and the psychic still sees the outcome as being favourable - then is the fact that the psychic sees a favourable outcome a failed prediction? Just because some interim events did not come to pass?
--- Quote from: sunandmoon on September 06, 2012, 02:33:11 PM ---This brings us back to: when do you just say it hasn't happened. If a psychic says a person will be back in your life by October 2012, at what point do you say ok they were wrong? November 2012? October 2013? Beyond?

If a psychic is NOT good with timing then they shouldn't be giving dates, just outcomes. Dave on CP rarely will give timing as he doesn't believe in it - to me that's being honest.

--- End quote ---

elcaliente:

--- Quote from: SomethingBetter on September 06, 2012, 02:38:32 PM --- Did you have to give info/could you ask a test question that they got correctly/could they give an accurate short term prediction, etc.


--- End quote ---
What sort of test question do people use to measure the psychic's accuracy?

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page

[*] Previous page